The Research and Application of Systematic Technologies for Reducing Tobacco-Specific N-Nitrosamines in Tobacco and Cigarette Smoke

Research Article

Ann Agric Crop Sci. 2020; 5(2): 1063.

The Research and Application of Systematic Technologies for Reducing Tobacco-Specific N-Nitrosamines in Tobacco and Cigarette Smoke

Bai R1, Zhou J1*, Zhang J1, Yang C2, Shi H3, Liu W4, Xu T1, Ma Y1, Liu X1, Yang J2, Wang J3, Yang Z1, Zheng X1, Zhang C1 and Chang X1

1Technical Center of Beijing Cigarette Factory, Shanghai Tobacco Group Corp., Ltd., China

2Hubei Tobacco Research Institute, China

3Henan Agriculture University, China

4Yunnan Rescend Tobacco Technology Group Corp., China

*Corresponding author: Zhou Jun, Technical Center of Beijing Cigarette Factory, Shanghai Tobacco Group Corp., Ltd., 101121, Beijing, China

Received: May 08, 2020; Accepted: May 29 2020; Published: June 05, 2020

Abstract

The systematic technologies for reducing cancerogenic Tobacco-Specific N-nitrosamines (TSNAs) in both agricultural and industrial area were developed and applied. The TSNA levels for the upper and middle leaves of burley tobacco could be reduced 23.0% and 23.9%, respectively, by foliage spray of purslane extract during tobacco cultivation. Through breed improvement of Maryland tobacco Wufeng#1to reduce nicotine conversion rate, TSNA levels for the upper and middle leaves of Maryland tobacco could be reduced 66.3% and 70.1%, respectively. By spraying 4.5% (W/W) of purslane extract and 0.4% (W/W) nanometer silica dispersion liquid during threshing and redrying, the TSNA level of tobacco could be reduced 36.0% and 20.5%, respectively, compared with that of the control. The level of 4-(methylnitrosamino)-1-(3-pyridyl)-1-butanone (NNK) in the cigarette smoke could be selectively reduced 34.6% when 5% (W/W) of cytochrome P450 recombinase was added to processed burley tobacco in processing. Using 10% of reconstituted tobacco processed with 10% (W/W) of nanometer silica and 4% of cytochrome P450 recombinase could result in 20.0% decrease of TSNAs in cigarette smoke. The TSNA level in cigarette smoke could be reduced 24.1% by using complex cigarette filter containing 0.6 mg of modified nanometer silica and 16.8 mg of macroporous silica gel instead of cellulose acetate filter with the similar parameters. All the above TSNA reduction technologies combined and applied in cigarette manufacture could approach the selective reduction of 58% of TSNAs in cigarette smoke and the 45% decrease of cigarette hazard index.

Keywords: Tobacco-specific nitrosamines; Reduction; Systematic technologies; Research; Application

Abbreviations

TSNAs: Tobacco-Specific N-Nitrosamines; NNK: (4-(N-methyl-N-nitrosamino)-1-(3-pyridyl)-1-butanone); NNN: N’-nitrosonornicotine; NAT: N’-nitrosoanatabine; NAB: N’- nitrosoanabasine; DRIFTS: Diffuse Reflectance Infrared Fourier Transform Spectroscopy; OPB: 4-oxo-4-(3-pyridyl) Butanal; HPB: 4-hydroxy-1-(3-pyridyl) -1-butanone.

Introduction

As a type of carcinogenic N-nitroso compound, Tobacco Specific N-nitrosamines (TSNAs) are products of the nitrozation reaction between tobacco alkaloids and nitrite [1]. There are four main types of TSNAs: NNK, (4-(N-methyl-N-nitrosamino)-1-(3- pyridyl)-1-butanone), NNN (N’-nitrosonornicotine), NAT (N’- nitrosoanatabine), and NAB (N’-nitrosoanabasine). NNK and NNN are potential carcinogens for rodents and are classified as carcinogens on Cancer Group I by International Agency for Research [2-4]. TSNAs are found in tobacco leaves and cigarette smoke, but are present in very small (almost negligible) amounts in green tobacco leaves. The formation and accumulation of TSNAs mainly occurs during curing and storage [5-6]. Some TSNAs in cigarette smoke are transferred directly from tobacco, while others are formed and transmitted during smoking [7]. Comprehensive and systematic studies on technologies reducing TSNA levels for tobacco and cigarette smoke are of important significance for reducing the risk of smoking.

Multiple TSNA-reducing technologies are currently available. Some lower TSNA release was achieved by using longer filter tip, filter tip ventilation, tipping paper ventilation and cigarette paper ventilation or using cigarette papers with faster static burn rates [8- 10]. While these methods do reduce TSNA release in some extent, there are significant draw backs; they alter the sensory quality of cigarettes due to the reduction of aromatic compounds in cigarette smoke [11-12]. Furthermore, there is no selectivity in the reduction of TSNAs. Some technologies are still under laboratory development and the new materials involved are either expensive or require complex preparatory techniques [13-15], which hampers industrial application. Moreover, the lack of variety for the current TSNA reduction techniques is an impediment to the development of a full technological series that lends itself easily to comprehensive and systematic applications.

From the perspective of tobacco agriculture and industry in which the reduction of TSNA levels can be achieved, this article provided a systematic series of applicable technologies for reducing TSNAs in tobacco and cigarette smoke. We examined tobacco cultivation, threshing and redrying, storage of tobacco, and cigarette processing to provide useful data and technical references to researchers studying technologies that aim to reduce the risk posed by smoking.

Materials and Methods

Experimental material

Burley tobacco -Eyan#1, TN90LC and TN86, Maryland tobacco -Wufeng#1, Wufeng#1 LC, flue-cured tobacco Yun 87 and purslane extract were obtained from Hubei Tobacco Research Institute. Nanometer silica was bought from Tai Hong Sheng Da New Material Co., Ltd., Tangshan, China). Cytochrome P450 recombinase was obtained from Beijing Ming Bo FeiScietific and Technological Company, Ltd, Beijing, China. Macroporous silica gel was bought from Anhui Liang ChenGui Yuan New Material Co., Ltd., Luan, China).NNN, NAT, NAB, NNK, NNN-d4, NAT-d4, NAB-d4, and NNK-d4 (purity of all >98%) were obtained from TRC Ltd, Canada. Glycol was bought from Guangzhou Xian Yan chemical company, Ltd, Guangzhou, China.

Experimental methods

TSNA reduction during tobacco agriculture processes: Maryland tobacco Wufeng#1 was used as research object. Screening was conducted on the nicotine conversion rate of this variety and non-transformants were cultivated for breed improvement. The nicotine conversion rate of tobacco leaves [16] and TSNA contents were measured [17] to compare changes in both parameters.

Purslane extract was made by filtrating fresh purslane that was mashed and ground in clean water at a purslane to water ratio of 1:1. On the day of tobacco topping, the extract was sprayed evenly on the foliage surface of burley tobacco Eyan#1 at 900L/ha. Tobacco leaves sprayed with water were employed as control. TSNA levels were measured after leaves had ripened and been collected and cured.

TSNA reduction during threshing and redrying: Burley tobacco Eyan#1 was used as research object in the experiment. Tobacco leaves were topped and de-stemmed. Before the tobacco leaves were put in the redrying machine, jute lint removal had been done. Purslane extracts accounting for 4.5% of the weight of the tobacco leaves and at a concentration of 12.5%, 25% and 50% was mixed to form a liquid suspension. The preparation was atomized by air compression and evenly automatically sprayed onto tobacco leaves. After redrying, the leaves were compared in terms of TSNA level differences with the control that were sprayed with water.

Flue-cured tobacco Yun 87 was used in the experiment. Nanometer silica was mixed with water and glycol to make dispersion liquid (10:88:2, W/W). The preparation was atomized by air compression and evenly automatically sprayed onto tobacco leaves (4%, W/W). Then the processed tobacco leaves were put into redrying machine for redrying. Nanometer silica-free tobacco leaves were used as the control. TSNA levels of both groups were measured after one year of natural storage under identical circumstances. In-situ infrared spectroscopic scanning was also conducted on the nanometer silica taken from nanometer silica processed tobacco and ordinary nanometer silica by Bruker Vertex 70 using a Diffuse Reflectance Infrared Fourier Transform Spectroscopy (DRIFTS).

TSNA formation inhibition during tobacco storage: Burley tobacco Eyan#1 and Maryland tobacco Wufeng#1 were used in the experiment. After threshing and redrying, tobacco leaves were stored for 2 years at a temperature of 20oC. The difference in TSNA levels was compared with the control stored at ambient temperature (the storage temperature changed along with the ambient temperature).

Burley tobacco TN86 was used in the experiment. After threshing and redrying, tobacco leaves were packaged in cartons (ordinary packaging), plastic bags, and vacuum packaging, and then stored naturally under identical circumstances for one year. Leaves packaged in cartons were used as the control. The levels of TSNAs and neutral aroma constituents [18] of the tobacco with different packaging were measured.

TSNA reduction during cigarette manufacturing: Cytochrome P450 recombinase (5% of the weight of burley tobacco leaves) was mixed into the flavor preparations. During the flavor spraying procedure, a foliage spray of the cytochrome P450 recombinase mixture was automatically applied to burley tobacco leaves evenly by the atomization of compressed air. After 2 hours of storage, processing was conducted in accordance with the leaf group formula for cigarette manufacturing. Cigarettes made in the absence of cytochrome P450 recombinase were the control. The amount of TSNAs in the mainstream smoke of the experimental cigarettes and the control was determined [19].

During the processing of reconstituted tobacco leaves, cytochrome P450 recombinase was added to the concentrate prepared after raw tobacco materials had been extracted. The volume added accounted for 4% (W/W) of the concentrate. After 24 hours, the concentrate in which NNK had been fully degraded by cytochrome P450 recombinase was formed into a coating liquid and 10% (W/W) nanometer silica was added. The mixture was applied to tobacco leaves by dip-coating to produce functionally reconstituted tobacco for reducing TSNAs. Cigarettes were manufactured with the tobacco shreds containing 10% of the functional reconstituted tobacco. Cigarettes made with the tobacco shreds containing 10% of ordinary reconstituted tobacco instead of the functional reconstituted tobacco were used as the control. The levels of TSNAs in the mainstream smoke of the experimental cigarettes and the control were measured.

During the manufacture of cigarette filters, modified nanometer silica was evenly distributed in glycerin triacetate at 8%W/W). The preparation was then evenly sprayed onto acetate tow at an amount of 8%W/W). At the same time, macroporous silica gel granules were added to acetate tow at 1.12mg/mm. The feeding filter rods were combined with ordinary cellulose acetate filter rods at a ratio of 15:10 for the manufacture of complex filter rods. The complex filter rods were used in the manufacture of cigarettes. Cigarettes using ordinary filters with the similar parameters and the same tobacco shreds were employed as the control. The amount of TSNAs in the mainstream smoke of the experimental cigarettes and the control was determined.

Application of the systematic TSNA-reducing technologies: From 2011-2017, the above TSNA-reducing technologies were gradually applied in new cigarette products development and commercial cigarettes maintenance. For example, Zhongnanhai (ZNH) is a key cigarette brand that the systematic TSNA-reducing technologies were applied. The level of TSNAs in the cigarette smoke and cigarette hazard index (H index = [YCO/14.2 + YHCN/146.3 + YNNK/5.5 + YNH3/8.1 + YB[a]P/10.9 + YPHE/17.4 + YCRO/18.6] × 10/7, where Y is the yield of a hazardous component in mainstream cigarette smoke) for product ZNH were checked annually.

All the above TSNA-reducing technologies were applied in the development of product B, which was a newly developed product with a designed tar level of 8 mg/cig. Cigarettes manufactured without using the above TSNA-reducing technologies, but using the ordinary cigarette materials of similar parameters and same manufacturing parameters were used as the control.

Results and Discussion

TSNAs reduction in tobacco agriculture field

TSNA reduction by breed improvement: Wufeng#1 LC with low nicotine conversion rate was obtained by culturing non-transformed tobacco plant through nicotine conversion rate screening. Compared to Wufeng#1, the nicotine conversion rate for Wufeng#1 LC decreased by 85.33%, from 16.50% to 2.42%. The NNN level and the TSNA level for the upper leaves decreased by 73.84% and 66.28%, respectively, compared with the control. The NNN level and the TSNA level for the middle leaves decreased by 77.09% and 70.10%, respectively, compared with the control. The results are shown in Table 1.