Investigation of Cu and Zn into Farmlands Irrigated with Livestock Wastewaters Using Nemerow Pollution Index

Shui-Wen Chang Chien; You-Cheng Chen; Cheng-Chung Liu

Research Article

Austin J Environ Toxico. 2024; 10(1): 1046.

Investigation of Cu and Zn into Farmlands Irrigated with Livestock Wastewaters Using Nemerow Pollution Index

Shui-Wen Chang Chien¹; You-Cheng Chen¹; Cheng-Chung Liu²*

¹Department of Environmental Engineering and Management, Chaoyang University of Technology, Taichung, Taiwan

²Department of Environmental Engineering, National Ilan University, Ilan, Taiwan

*Corresponding author: Cheng-Chung Liu Department of Environmental Engineering, National Ilan University, Ilan, Taiwan. Tel: (0118863) 935-7400 (O); Fax: (0118863) 936-7642 Email: [email protected]

Received: November 29, 2023 Accepted: January 03, 2024 Published: January 10, 2024

Abstract

Animal husbandry flourishes in Yunlin County, Taiwan. Livestock wastewater has been commonly used as a fertilizer for decades. Such wastewater usually contains large amounts of Cu and Zn; however, over-irrigation deteriorates farmland and pollutes groundwater. Lunbei (ranches), Shuilin (pig farms), and Huwei (pig farms) townships were selected in the county for this study. To determine the accumulation of Cu and Zn in soils after irrigation, the single-factor pollution index (PI) and Nemerow pollution index (PN) were used to evaluate the pollution level and metal hazard at several monitoring sites within the irrigation group over four years. Furthermore, the data were used to identify sites with a high pollution potential. Speciation investigations of Cu and Zn were conducted to analyze their potential environmental threats. All PI levels were below 1.0, indicating that all the monitoring points were non-polluting. Although the calculated PN levels increased annually, the PN levels obtained in the third year were all lower than the safety threshold of 0.7. After irrigation, most of the available Cu and Zn in the soil were bound to organic matter and Fe-Mn oxyhydroxide, possibly posing environmental risks. Cu had a higher threat potential than Zn. The potential threat caused by irrigation with cow manure urine was more than that caused by irrigation with pig manure urine.

Keywords: Copper; Livestock wastewater; Nemerow index; Zinc

Capsule

The Nemerow pollution index is useful for monitoring the accumulation of toxic metals in soil.

Introduction

Animal husbandry is an important agricultural activity in Taiwan, accounting for 32% of the entire agricultural production as reported in the Annual Report of the Council of Agriculture, Executive Yuan (Taiwan). However, considerable amounts of wastewater are produced daily in animal husbandry. In earlier years, they were discharged into rivers or ditches without treatment, causing severe environmental pollution [1]. Livestock wastewater is rich in nutrients and organic matter, including nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium. In addition, wastewater utilized as a fertilizer increases soil fertility and therefore lowers the use of chemical fertilizers, as well as achieves waste resource recovery.

In recent years, authorities in Taiwan’s agricultural affairs have implemented a livestock wastewater reuse policy. In 2009, the Council of Agriculture cooperated with researchers to conduct a test program for livestock wastewater reuse to encourage resource recovery from livestock wastewater [2]. Livestock and cropland farmers were invited to participate in forums and observation tours to understand the policy. The Environmental Protection Administration has also subsidized local governments to buy vehicles, irrigation tools, and storage tanks to encourage farmers to irrigate their croplands with livestock wastewater. However, Cu and Zn are commonly added to livestock feed as growth regulators to reduce growth time and prevent diseases [3]. Only 10–20% of Cu or Zn can be absorbed into the livestock body, but the residual Cu and Zn are excreted through manure and finally transferred to the livestock wastewater [4,5]. When considerable amounts of Cu and Zn are continuously brought into farmland through irrigation, accumulation occurs, encouraging their over-uptake. Eventually, metals are transferred to the human body through the food chain, posing health risks [6,7]. Heavy metals are considered persistent environmental pollutants. Organisms are difficult to degrade and thus have longer biological half-lives. A test result of Broadbalk agriculture from Rothamsted Research showed that the Cu and Zn concentrations in soil increased by approximately 60% after composting over 160 years [8]. Therefore, the long-term monitoring of irrigated croplands is necessary.

The Nemerow pollution index (PN), which helps determine heavy metals posing the greatest risk to a single environment, has been used to assess the effect of heavy metals on contaminated rivers or the effect of groundwater on plant growth in paddy soils [9]. An area with a high PN level indicates the area is severely polluted and requires increased attention [10,11]. Risk assessment of cropland to heavy metals allows us to determine the degree of pollution, which is classified as a high-, middle-, or low-risk indicator. This is also used to evaluate the extent to which cropland is used for agriculture if Cu and Zn consistently accumulate in the soil [12]. The single-factor (PI) and the Nemerow (PN) pollution indices are typical environmental indicators [13]. PI calculates the pollution level of each metal in the soil, and PN the comprehensive pollution impact of heavy metals [14]. They have been used to evaluate the potential of heavy metals in farms in Taiwan [15], to calculate the distribution of metalliferous sediments on the surface of the Yellow River in China [16], and to estimate the pollution of soil near steel mills in Iran [17].

This study aimed to use the Nemerow pollution index to (1) examine the accumulation of Cu and Zn in croplands after irrigation using livestock wastewater, (2) obtain evaluation data by calculating the Cu and Zn concentrations through indicators, (3) grade the soil using the monitoring point, and (4) identify the form of Cu and Zn in the irrigated croplands. These data were summarized, and the potential environmental threats through long-term irrigation were evaluated.

Methodology

Survey and Sampling Areas

Yunlin County is among the top three animal producers in Taiwan. Based on a report from the Council of Agriculture in 2020, the Yunlin area produces 28.4% of pigs in Taiwan. Therefore, Yunlin was selected as the survey area in this study. Three townships in this county, namely, Lunbei (ranches), Shuilin (pig farms), and Huwei (pig farms) were identified as major sampling areas (Figure 1). The document defines “irrigation” as using livestock wastewater as fertilizer in specific croplands. Irrigation in the Shuilin and Huwei areas involved pouring wastewater from a tank car and flooding the cropland, whereas in the Lunbei area, a tank car was coupled with furrow irrigation. Sampling was conducted during the dry season (March and May) and the rainy season (July and September) because the elemental contents of soil are easily affected by moisture. Table 1 shows the farm type, type of irrigation wastewater, number of monitoring points, and monitoring period for the experimental areas. The term “spare monitoring point” was defined as an irrigated monitoring point without livestock wastewater. Solid–liquid-separated raw water containing solid manure was used to irrigate the Lunbei area. Anaerobic swine wastewater that underwent a two-stage treatment without solid manure was applied to the Shuilin area. Aerobic swine wastewater that underwent a three-stage treatment and contained solid manure was used to irrigate the Huwei area.

Table 1: Survey areas and monitoring period.




  
    Area
    Farm type
    Type of irrigation waste water
    Number of monitoring points
    Monitoring period
    Spare monitoring point
    Monitoring period
  
  
    Lunbei
    cattle farms
    solid-liquid separated raw water
    8
    2018–2019
    none
    none
  
  
    Shuilin
    pig farms
    anaerobic swine wastewater
    2
    2016–2019
    1
    2017–2019
  
  
    Huwei
    pig farms
    aerobic swine wastewater
    3
    2016–2019
    1
    2017–2019



Table 1: Survey areas and monitoring period.

Figure 1: Soil sampling areas of this study.

    
    
    Figure 1: Soil sampling areas of this study.

Soil Sampling and Analysis

Irrigation wells are commonly established in croplands in Yulin County, Taiwan. Considerable groundwater is extracted from irrigation wells for paddy rice growth during the dry season. Three sampling sites were established in the croplands at each monitoring point. They were individually aligned 3, 6, and 9 m from the irrigation inlet. An auger was used to collect an adequate amount of topsoil (0–15 cm) and subsoil (15–30 cm) from each site. However, avoiding collecting soil mixed with fertilizer and manure during sampling is necessary. Triplicate sampling was performed for each site but the soil samples were mixed thoroughly. After air-drying, the soil samples were broken, ground, and passed through 2- and 10-mm sieves. The pre-treated samples were stored in plastic cans at room temperature. Livestock wastewater and groundwater extracted from the irrigation wells were also collected for analysis. After collection, the water sampling bottles were sealed and preserved in cooling equipment.

The soil pH was measured at a 1:1 soil-water ratio (w/v) using a pH meter (Sartorius PB-10, Germany). Electrical Conductivity (EC) was measured at a 1:5 soil-water ratio (w/v) using an electrical conductivity meter (SUNTEX SC 2300, Taiwan). The Cu and Zn concentrations were analyzed using inductively coupled plasma with an atomic emission spectrometer (iCAP 6300, USA) after digestion in an aqua regia solution (1:3 conc. HNO3:conc. HCl (v/v)). The Total Organic Carbon (TOC) content was determined using the combustion-infrared absorption method [18]. Total nitrogen was determined using the Kjeldahl method. The carbon-nitrogen ratio was calculated from the results of the total organic carbon and total nitrogen analyses. The pH and EC of the water samples were measured using a pH meter and electrical conductivity meter, respectively. The Cu and Zn concentrations in the water samples were determined using microwave-assisted acid degradation treatment. The ammonia nitrogen (NH3-N) contents of the water samples were determined using the phenate method [19]. The sequential extraction study used the method proposed by Tessier et al. [20], which was used to ascertain the speciation of Cu and Zn in different soil fractions after long-term irrigation with livestock wastewater. All chemicals used in this study were reagent grade and all experiments were conducted in triplicate.

Nemerow Pollution Iindex

The Nemerow pollution index (PN) has been used to evaluate the combined effects of heavy metals in soil [8,21,22]. The PN calculates the average of the evaluated heavy metals and weighs the most polluted metal items; it also dominates the variation in every polluted item. The single-factor pollution index (PI), which calculates pollutant standards for every heavy metal, provides a simple and fast evaluation of single pollutants in the soil to recognize individual items that cause the highest pollution in soil [13,22]. PI and PN were calculated using the following

PI: single factor pollution index

Ci: measured concentration of pollutant i

Csi: the value of evaluation standards of pollutant i

PN: Nemerow pollution index

n: pollutant items on the evaluation

PIi: pollution index of the pollutant i

PImax: pollutant items that have the highest pollution index

This study used the Nemerow pollution index to evaluate the annual effects of Cu and Zn on croplands irrigated with livestock wastewater. The irrigation curb standard was defined as 85% of soil pollution monitoring standards. Thus, 102 ppm (Cu) and 221 ppm (Zn) were used as evaluation standard values for the calculation. The annual PI, PN, and mean concentrations of Cu and Zn were calculated according to the process shown in Figure 2.

Figure 2: Process of calculation for PI and PN.

    
    
    Figure 2: Process of calculation for PI and PN.

The evaluation standards for the pollution index (PI) and the Nemerow pollution index (PN) are presented in Table 2. The PI is graded to five levels from no pollution PI=1.0 to high pollution PI>5.0, whereas the PN is also graded to five levels from the safe level (PN0.7) to serious contamination (PN>3.0).

Table 2: Evaluation standard for single factor pollution index and Nemerow pollution index.




  
    Evaluation level 
    Single factor PI
    Evaluation level
    Nemerow PN
  
  
    No pollution
    PI.0 
    Safe level
    PN0.7
  
  
    Slight pollution
    1.02.0 
    Alert level
    0.7PN1.0
  
  
    Mild pollution
    2.03.0 
    Mild pollution
    1.0PN2.0
  
  
    Medium pollution
    3.05.0 
    Medium pollution
    2.0PN3.0
  
  
    High pollution
    5.0PI 
    Heavy pollution
    3.0PN
  
  
    Data sources:    (Fei et al., 2019) and; Wang et al., 2019)



Table 2: Evaluation standard for single factor pollution index and Nemerow pollution index.

Results and Discussion

Fundamental Properties of Livestock Wastewater and Solid Manure

Table 3 shows the basic properties and characteristics of used livestock wastewater. Variations were significant in the pH levels of all wastewaters (3.1–6.7%). The average pH level of wastewater irrigated in Huwei was significantly higher than others. This was attributed to the aerobic wastewater treatment process. Alkali liquor is commonly added to similar wastewater because the nitrification consumes alkali during the treatment, leading to water maintenance at pH 8.0 to 8.6 [25]. Annual EC averages from every stock farm ranged from 2,687 to 5,637 μS cm-1. Moreover, the annual Cu averages ranged from 0.11 to 2.80 mg L-1, and the annual Zn averages ranged from 0.59 to 13.5 mg L-1, indicating that properties among the swine wastewater varied significantly. Pig consumes more protein, adipose, and carbohydrate than cattle. When the pig excretes these substances, they gradually decompose to macromolecules by microorganisms or hydrolyze to dissolve salt ions. This leads to EC increasing in the manure. Cu and Zn are commonly added into the feed to make the pigs grow faster during their growth period, which also causes the swine wastewaters to have a high variability related to their contents. In Japan, Zn dosage in feed is recommended between 60 and 100 mg kg-1 when the piglets weigh 1 to 35 kg. Adequate Cu and Zn intakes are required for dairy cattle to maintain their health and high milk yield. The Cu and Zn demand for dairy cattle are 10 and 40 mg kg-1, respectively, in the feed. Evidently, the Cu and Zn contents in untreated pig solid manure were approximately six times higher than those of cattle (Table 4) [26,27]. As shown in Table 3, annual averages of NH3-N and TOC in the livestock wastewaters also appear to have notable differences, with their coefficients of variation ranging from 49% to 97%. This was attributed to different management and treatments among the stock farms. The nitrogen removal process in the oxic tank caused a large change in NH3-N content in Huwei soil. The annual TOC average in Lunbe soil, 736 mg L-1, was much higher than that of the others, with the coefficients of variation ranging from 11% to 56%. It was speculated that the cattle consumed staple food, Pennisetum, to obtain plenty of organic carbon, resulting in higher TOC content in raw water than in the swine water.

Table 3: The properties of livestock wastewaters from different areas.




  
    Area
    Stock farm
    Applied livestock wastewater 
     
    ——– Monitoring item of livestock    wastewater ——
  
  
    pH
    EC
    Cu
    Zn
    NH3-N
    TOCb
  
  
     
     
     
     
     
    μS cm-1
    ————mg L-1————
  
  
    Lunbei
    Cattle farms
    Solid-liquid separated raw water 
    Annual

      averagea
    7.3±0.2

      (3.1%)
    2687±463

      (17%)
    0.30±0.17

      (57%)
    1.32±0.63

      (48%)
    117±57

      (49%)
    736±254

      (35%)
  
  
    Shuilin
    Pig farms
    Anaerobic swine wastewater
    7.1±0.5

      (6.7%)
    4519±1468

      (32%)
    2.80±4.51

      (162%)
    13.5±14.6

      (109%)
    393±186

      (48%)
    73.4±8.03

      (11%)
  
  
    Huwei
    Pig farms
    Aerobic swine wastewater
    8.2±0.4

      (4.4%)
    5637±2940

      (52%)
    0.11±0.13

      (126%)
    0.59±1.24

      (209%)
    422±411

      (97%)
    68.8±38.8

      (56%)
  
  
    (%) presents coefficient of variation, obtained    from that standard deviation divided by mean value and multiplied by one    hundred.

      a: annual average was the mean of monitoring    levels in each area, Lunbei 2018–2019 (n=8). Shuilin and Huwei 2016–2019    (n=16)

      b: Total    organic carbon; only three samples were tested from May, 2019 to September,    2019 (n=3).



Table 3: The properties of livestock wastewaters from different areas.

Table 4: The properties of solid manure from different areas.




  
    Area
    Stock farm
    Testing items of the manure
  
  
    EC
    Cu
    Zn
  
  
     
     
    μS cm-1
    ——mg kg-1——
  
  
    Lunbei
    Cattle farms
    1196
    16.0
    161
  
  
    Huwei 
    Pig farms
    4970
    92.3
    918



Table 4: The properties of solid manure from different areas.

Cu and Zn in Soils

The average Cu and Zn concentrations in the soils of the three farms are presented in Table 5. The irrigated soils’ average Cu concentrations ranged from 20.5 to 25.4 mg kg-1, and the average Zn concentration ranged from 138 to 148 mg kg-1. In contrast, for the soil without irrigation (control group), average Cu concentrations ranged from 7.90 to 22.5 mg kg-1, and average Zn concentrations ranged from 70.5 to 95.2 mg kg-1. The results indicated that the Cu and Zn concentrations in the irrigated soils were always far lower than the irrigation curb standard. The soils in the Huwei area had higher original Cu content than those in the other areas. Moreover, the Cu content had higher variability than the Zn content because soil particles cannot quickly adsorb or release Zn2+ ions [28]. Zn2+ ions have a full electron configuration, [Ar] 3d104s0; thus, they have a weaker electrical attraction to negatively charged sites on soil minerals and organic matter [29]. As a result, the Zn content exhibited lower variability than the Cu content.

Table 5: Cu and Zn concentrations in investigated croplands.




  
    Area
    Monitoring item of the soil
  
  
    Cu
    Zn
  
  
     
    ————mg kg-1—————
  
  
    Lunbei
    20.5±4.27 (21%)
    138±18.3 (13%)
  
  
    Shuilin 
    25.0±5.06 (20%)
    148±22.7 (15%)
  
  
    Control group of Shuilin 
    7.90±1.91 (24%)
    70.5±8.20 (12%)
  
  
    Huwei
    25.4±4.14 (16%)
    142±16.4 (12%)
  
  
    Control group of Huwei
    22.5±3.37 (15%)
    95.2±11.2 (12%)
  
  
    (%) presents coefficient of variation, obtained    from that standard deviation divided by mean value and multiplied by one    hundred 

      Annual    average is the mean of monitoring levels in each area: Lunbei 2018–2019    (n=8), Shuilin and Huwei 2016–2019 (n=16), and the control group 2017–2019    (n=12).



Table 5: Cu and Zn concentrations in investigated croplands.

Nemerow Pollution Index and Analysis of Metal Form

Figures 3 and 4 show the PIs evaluated for Cu and Zn in the monitored soils. All the PI values of Zn were higher than those of Cu, indicating that Zn had a higher potential hazard. This may be attributed to the Zn content, which was approximately five times the Cu content in the livestock wastewater and ten times the Cu content in the manure. Moreover, Zn showed a higher background concentration (120 ppm) in the soil than Cu (50 ppm) in Taiwan. This has led to Zn in the monitored soil posing a higher potential environmental threat. The PI values of Cu and Zn at each monitoring point were within the non-pollution level range (PI=1.0) in 2019. Nevertheless, the PI values of Zn (0.8 and 0.96) at monitoring sites 7 and 8 were very close to a slight pollution level (PI>1.0) in 2018, and the PI value of Cu in monitoring point 8 was higher than any other ones. Therefore, although the PI level of Cu decreased in 2019, the soil at monitoring point 8 requires increased attention to be irrigated.

Figure 3: Pollution Index (PI) of monitored croplands in Shueilin and Huwei areas over the years. PI=1.0: non-pollution level, PI>1.0: slight pollution level, S: Shueilin, H: Huwei.

    
    
    Figure 3: Pollution Index (PI) of monitored croplands in Shueilin and Huwei areas over the years. PI=1.0: non-pollution level, PI>1.0: slight pollution level, S: Shueilin, H: Huwei.

Figure 4: Pollution Index (PI) of the monitored croplands in the Lunbei area over the years. PI=1.0: non-pollution level, PI>1.0: slight pollution level, L: Lunbei.

    
    
    Figure 4: Pollution Index (PI) of the monitored croplands in the Lunbei area over the years. PI=1.0: non-pollution level, PI>1.0: slight pollution level, L: Lunbei.

Figures 5 and 6 show that the PN levels obtained from Shuilin and Huwei increased annually. The PN levels from the first monitoring point in Huwei and monitoring point 7 in Lunbei were the same (0.69), and in 2018, the condition was very close to the alert level (PN>0.7). However, the PN level of monitoring point 8 in Lunbei was calculated at 0.83 in the same year. Although this level decreased below the safe level (PN=0.7) in 2019, Cu and Zn may have continued accumulating.

Investigation of Cu and Zn into Farmlands Irrigated with Livestock Wastewaters Using Nemerow Pollution Index

Abstract

Introduction

Methodology

Survey and Sampling Areas

Soil Sampling and Analysis

Nemerow Pollution Iindex

Results and Discussion

Fundamental Properties of Livestock Wastewater and Solid Manure

Cu and Zn in Soils

Nemerow Pollution Index and Analysis of Metal Form

Conclusion

References