Research Article
Ann Hematol Onco. 2023; 10(3): 1427.
Perspectives of Pediatric Patients, Parents, and Healthcare Providers on the Disclosure of a Leukemia Diagnosis and the Investigation of Internalizing Symptoms in Children with Leukemia
Yusuf Yasar¹; Zuhre Kaya¹*; Esra Guney²; Serap Kirkiz¹; Ulker Kocak¹
1Department of Pediatric Hematology, Faculty of Medicine, Gazi University, Ankara, Turkey
2Department of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, Faculty of Medicine, Gazi University, Ankara, Turkey.
*Corresponding author: Kaya Zuhre Department of Pediatric Hematology, Faculty of Medicine, Gazi University, Tip Fakultesi, Cocuk Sagligi ve Hastaliklari Anabilim Dali, Cocuk Hematoloji Bilimdali, Besevler 06500, Ankara, Turkey. Phone: +903122026025 E-mail: [email protected]
Received: April 08, 2023 Accepted: May 27, 2023 Published: June 03, 2023
Abstract
Background: The purpose of this study was to examine study participants’ knowledge, attitudes, anxiety, and coping strategies following a leukemia diagnosis.
Study Design: The 350 participants included 100 pediatric patients, 100 parents, and 150 healthcare providers. The survey was filled out by all participants. Patients’ and Parents’ perceptions of their children’s anxiety levels were also evaluated using the Revised Child Anxiety and Depression Scale.
Results: In total, 84 pediatric patients were aware of their leukemia diagnosis, but the remaining 16 were not at the time of the survey. Thirteen (82%) of the 16 patients were under the age of seven at the time of diagnosis. Parents and health care providers strongly agreed that leukemia diagnosis should be disclosed directly to children. Compared with healthcare providers, parents were significantly more likely to opt for disclosure after starting chemotherapy by the parents in the doctor’s office (p<0.05). Parent’s perceptions of their children’s anxiety levels were significantly higher than patients’ (p<0.05). Healthcare providers responded to the survey that 32% of the pediatrician, 16% of nurses, and 86% of interns received training on delivering bad news.
Conclusions: Our research shows that there is no agreement among healthcare providers and patients’ parents about who, when, and where to inform children of a leukemia diagnosis. The findings also highlight the importance of reinforming children diagnosed at less than 7 years when they are older. Additionally, delivering bad news training to healthcare providers and providing psychological support to parents and adolescents have a positive impact.
Keywords: Leukemia diagnosis; Anxiety; Children; Health care provider; Parents
Introduction
A recent comprehensive review and numerous systematic studies focused on cancer-specific information and communication for patients, but there is still no consensus on the appropriate person, time, and place to inform patients and their relatives of a cancer diagnosis and prognosis [1-3]. Most information to date has been obtained from adult studies [4-14]. These have indicated that, for adult patients, good communication between patient and physician enhances the quality of life and reduces anxiety levels during cancer diagnosis and treatment. The cornerstone of this communication is, to tell the truth about the patient's diagnosis and prognosis [4,15]. Regardless, delivering bad news about diagnosis and prognosis to cancer patients is challenging for many reasons. The most important of these are pediatric age, knowledge levels, attitudes of the patient’s relatives, cultural and religious differences, and concern that the psychological devastation caused by the news may delay treatment. However, data on issues such as informing children, communicating with parents, and delivering bad news to healthcare providers about a leukemia diagnosis are scarce.
The aim of this study was to evaluate the impact of leukemia diagnosis on Turkish pediatric patients, their parents, and healthcare providers.
Materials and Methods
This cross-sectional study was carried out in our leukemia center. The Institutional Review Board approved the investigation, and patients or their parents gave informed consent.
Study Population
Three groups of participants were enrolled: pediatric leukemia patients (n=100), patients' parents (n=100), and healthcare providers (n=50). A total of 100 consecutive pediatric acute leukemia patients were enrolled. At the time of diagnosis, hematology specialists obtained routine institutional consent and assent forms from older patients (>12 years old) and parents of all pediatric patients. Only one parent (mothers; n=70, fathers; n=30) who accompanied their children during the chemotherapy period completed the survey. The healthcare providers were divided into three subgroups: pediatricians (n=50), interns (n=50), and nurses (n=50). Patients with lymphoma or solid tumors, or those over the age of 18, were excluded from the study.
Study Design
A survey was designed based on similar studies in the literature [7-14] as well as feedback from patients, parents, and healthcare providers. The survey's primary outcomes focused on how healthcare providers, children, and their parents perceived a leukemia diagnosis. The secondary outcomes assessed the anxiety and coping strategies of children, and their parents following a leukemia diagnosis. The importance of training for healthcare professionals on delivering bad news was the third outcome.
Study participants were invited to respond, and each completed this survey in written form for approximately 15-20 minutes in a quiet room. All pediatric patients were over the age of seven at the time of the survey. Of them, eighty-one percent had completed the leukemia protocol, while the remaining 19% were still receiving chemotherapy. Parents assisted children under the age of 12 in completing the survey. Most question items were designed as short answers (Yes or No), and some required detailed explanations (Table 1). The questions were composed so as to assess the knowledge level, attitudes, anxiety, and coping strategies of the Turkish participant groups after a leukemia diagnosis. Patients’ and Parents’ anxiety levels were also evaluated using the Revised Child Anxiety and Depression Scale. This scale was an internationally validated, standardized, and reliable anxiety and depression assessment tool [16]. The parents’ version was completed by parents, while the self-reported version was administered to patients (7-18 years of age). This survey contains 47 questions grouped under six items: Separation Anxiety, Social Phobia, Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder, Panic Disorder, Generalized Anxiety Disorder, and Major Depressive Disorder. A total score of more than 65 indicates that the individuals suffer from significant anxiety and depression. The Parents’ version evaluates parent reports of their child's anxiety and depression symptoms across the same contexts.
2- Gender:
3- Diagnosis:
4- Chemotherapy: o Ongoing o Completed
Questions for Healthcare Providers and Parents
1- Should the diagnosis of leukemia be disclosed to the pediatric patient?
o Yes o No
2- Who should tell the patient of the diagnosis and prognosis?
o Doctors oParents o Others
3- When should the information be given?
4- Where should the information be given?
o In the doctor's office
5- Who should be informed?
o Patient o Parents
6- Do you inform if a patient doesn't know diagnosis?
o Yes o No
7- If no, to whom would you direct it?
o Doctor o Parents o Others
8- Do you want to know the leukemia diagnosis and prognosis if you are the patient?
o Yes o No
Questions For Healthcare Providers
1- Have you received any training in delivering bad news to cancer patients?
2- What is your attitude to inform your patients about the leukemia diagnosis and prognosis?
o I always inform
o I usually inform
o I rarely inform
3- Do you think there is a need for such studies?
o Yes o No
Questions for Patients
1- Do you know the name of your disease?
o Yes o No
2- If no, do you want to know the diagnosis?
3- If yes, from whom did you learn the diagnosis?
o Doctor o Parents o Other
4- If yes, when did you learn?
o Before starting chemotherapy
o After starting chemotherapy
5- If yes, where did you learn it?
o In the doctor's office
o Outside the doctor's office
6- How did you feel when you learned the diagnosis?
o Anxiety o Fear o Shock o Other
7- Have you received any psychiatric support?
8- Have you taken any psychiatric medication?
o Yes o No
Table 1: Survey to evaluate the knowledge and attitudes of study participants about leukemia diagnosis.
Statistical Analysis
Data were analyzed using the SPSS version 22.0 (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA). Differences were compared using the Mann-Whitney U test and Chi-square test. Odds Ratios (ORs) were calculated with a 95% confidence interval (95% CI). Pearson correlation coefficient was used. P values <0.05 indicated statistical significance.
Results
All participants completed the survey. Participants’ demographic data are presented in Table 2.
Study participants
Pediatric patients (n, %)
100(29%)
Median-IQR* age (years)
13(7-17)
Gender
Male/Female
60(60%)/40(40%)
Diagnosis
ALL*/AML*
86(86%)/14(14%)
Chemotherapy status
Completed/Ongoing
81(81%)/19(19%)
Patients’ parents (n,%)
100(29%)
Median-IQR age (years)
39(18-78)
Gender
Male/Female
30(30%)/70(70%)
Healthcare providers (n,%)
150(42%)
Pediatricians (n,%)
50(14%)
Median-IQR* age (years)
28(24-40)
Gender
Male/Female
10(20%)/40(80%)
Nurses (n,%)
50(14%)
Median-IQR* age (years)
31(22-55)
Gender
Male/Female
4(4%)/46(96%)
Interns (n,%)
50(14%)
Median-IQR* age (years)
23(22-29)
Gender
Male/Female
26(52%)/24(48%)
*IQR: Interquartile Range; ALL: Acute Lymphoblastic Leukaemia; AML: Acute Myeloblastic Leukaemia.
Table 2: Demographic data of the study participants.
Patients’ Parents and Healthcare Providers-Specific Questionnaire
The survey results of healthcare providers and patients’ parents are summarized in Table 3. The patient’s parents (n=90; 90%) and health care providers (n=144; 96%) strongly agreed that a leukemia diagnosis should be disclosed directly to a pediatric patient. Of the 150 healthcare providers, 90% (n=136) stated this should be done by the attending physician, and 10% (n=14) by the patient's parents. For the 100 parents, the corresponding proportions for these answers were 81% (n=81) and 19% (n=19). Compared with healthcare providers, parents were significantly more likely to opt for disclosure by the patient’s parents (p<0.05). The rate of parents’ disclosure was 2.65 times higher than healthcare providers’ disclosure.
Healthcare Providers
�Patients’ Parents
p
OR [95CI%]
n=150
n=100
Should the patient be informed of the diagnosis and prognosis?
�Yes
�No
144(%96)
90(%90)
0.102
0.37(0.13-1.06)
6(%4)
10(%10)
Who should inform
�Doctor
136(%90)
81(%81)
0.02
2.65(1.22-5.76)
�Patients’ parents
14(%10)
19(%19)
When to inform
Before starting treatment
143(%95)
85(%85)
0.01
3.60(1.41-9.19)
After starting treatment
7(%5)
15(%15)
Where to inform?
�In the doctor's office
44(%29)
54(%54)
0
2.82(1.69-4.79)
�Outside the doctor's office
106(%71)
46(%46)
Whom to inform
�Patient
36(%24)
3(%3)
0
10.21( 3.0-34.10)
�Patients’ parents
114(%76)
97(%97)
Do you inform if a patient does not know the diagnosis,�
� I� inform
� I do not inform
49(%32)
36(%36)
0.586
1.15(0.68-1.97)
101(%68)
64(%64)
OR:Odds Ratio, 95CI%: Confidence interval
Table 3: The comparison of survey results of healthcare providers and patients’ parents.
Of the 150 healthcare providers, 95% (n=143) stated that the appropriate time to inform the patient about their diagnosis was before the start of chemotherapy, and 5% (n=7) after the start of chemotherapy. The corresponding proportion results for 100 parents were 85% (n=85) and 15% (n=15). Compared with healthcare providers, parents were significantly more likely to opt for disclosure after starting chemotherapy by the patient’s parents (p<0.05). The rate of parents’ disclosure after starting chemotherapy was 3.6 times higher than in healthcare providers’ disclosure after chemotherapy.
Of the 150 healthcare providers, 29% (n=44) answered that the appropriate place for pediatric patients to be informed of their leukemia diagnosis is the doctor's office, whereas 71% (n=106) answered outside the doctor's office. The corresponding proportions for the 100 parents were 54% (n=54) and 46% (n=46). Compared with healthcare providers, parents were significantly more likely to opt for disclosure in the doctor's office by the patient’s parents (p<0.05). The rate of parents’ disclosure in the doctor's office was 2.82 times higher than in healthcare providers’ disclosure.
Of the 150 healthcare providers, 24% (n=36) indicated that the patient should be the first person to know their diagnosis, whereas 76% (n=114) stated that a patient’s parents should be the first to know. For the 100 parents, the corresponding proportions were 3% (n=3) and 97% (n=97). Compared with healthcare providers, parents were significantly more likely to opt for knowledge of the first diagnosis by the patient’s parents (p<0.05). The rate of parents’ opinion about the first person who should know the first diagnosis of patients was 10.21 times higher than healthcare providers’ opinion.
Of 150 healthcare providers, 32% (n=49) were willing to inform their pediatric patients of their leukemia diagnosis if they had not learned it previously, while 68% (n=101) were unwilling to disclose it. Among 100 parents, the corresponding proportions were 36% (n=36) and 64% (n=64).
Healthcare providers responded to the questions about whether they had received “Delivering Bad News Training” before. Healthcare providers responded to the survey that 32% of the pediatrician, 16% of nurses, and 86% of interns received training on delivering bad news.
The Revised Child Anxiety and Depression Scale findings
There were 84(84%) pediatric patients who were aware of their leukemia diagnosis and 16(16%) children who were not during the survey. At the time of diagnosis, 68(80%) of 84 patients were over the age of 12 and the remaining 16(20%) were under the age of 12, but 13(82%) of 16 children were under the age of 7 and the remaining 3(18%) were over 7. Nineteen (19%) patients had already received chemotherapy when the study began; the remaining 81(81%) completed chemotherapy during the period the study was conducted. The parents' perceptions of their children's anxiety levels were significantly higher than the patients themselves (p<0.001). The anxiety scores of the parent’s perceptions of their children's anxiety levels and patients’ anxiety levels were strongly correlated (p<0.05, r=0.99) (Figure 1). The mean anxiety score for the nine adolescent patients who did not want to know their diagnosis was significantly higher than that for the 16 younger patients who desired to but did not know their diagnosis (50.6±24.1 vs. 32.4±15.1, respectively; p<0.05).
Figure 1: The relationship between the parent’s perceptions of their children’s anxiety levels and patients’ anxiety levels.
Discussion
A recent comprehensive review and numerous systematic studies focused on the best way to inform pediatric patients and their families about a cancer diagnosis and prognosis [1-3]. It is unknown to many pediatric leukemia specialists whether pediatric patients are aware of their diagnosis. The majority of cancer disclosure studies have been designed for adult cancer patients [4-14], and there is little data on cancer disclosure to pediatric patients and their parents. This research examined the impact of leukemia diagnosis on Turkish pediatric patients, parents, and healthcare providers.
Many studies on cancer disclosure in various countries, including Lebanon, Egypt, Greece, and Iran, found that nearly all participants agreed that patients should be informed directly [6-8,11,12]. Consistent with these results, 96% of the healthcare providers and parents in our study stated that children with leukemia should know their leukemia diagnosis and be informed by the attending physician. However, 97% of patients’ parents stated that information about diagnosis and prognosis should be provided to parents first, and 19% of this group indicated that they should be the one/s to disclose a cancer diagnosis to their child.
In the Lebanon study on the timing of cancer information disclosure, adult patients reported that they preferred to learn their diagnosis directly and prior to chemotherapy, whereas their family members preferred to learn after chemotherapy had begun [7]. Physicians and nurses stated that they were concerned about patients being shocked by the sudden disclosure of a cancer diagnosis. They also stated that they preferred to explain the diagnosis over a period of time according to each patient’s personal characteristics and that it is best to inform the patient together with nurses and relatives, as opposed to a single person conveying the news. They indicated that these approaches contribute to the success of treatment and healthy follow-up of cancer patients. In contrast, the majority of oncology nurses surveyed in China stated that cancer patients should be informed about their diagnosis in the early chemotherapy period [10]. Similarly, in our study, most healthcare providers declared that the appropriate time to inform a patient is before the start of treatment; however, 15% of parents felt that the news should be given after treatment has begun.
In total, 84 pediatric patients were aware of their leukemia diagnosis, but the remaining 16 were not at the time of the survey. Thirteen (82%) of the 16 patients were under the age of seven at the time of diagnosis. Similarly, in an adult survey conducted in Greece, 25% of patients stated that they did not want to know their diagnosis [13]. Another study conducted by Raz et al. found that quality of life was poor, and tolerance to mental pain was lower in children older than 12 years of age who were well informed about their disease [17]. A comprehensive study by Kadan-Lottick et al. investigated the negative impact of late cancer disclosure on 635 pediatric cancer patients [18]. Of the 216 patients who had leukemia, 32(5%) remained unaware of this at the time of the survey phone call at least 5 years after diagnosis. The authors stated that these patients should be informed about the leukemia diagnosis in order to monitor the long-term side effects of chemoradiotherapy [18]. Another study investigated disclosing a parent’s cancer diagnosis to children at an appropriate time based on the developmental and emotional stages of children. Results showed that children 3 years or younger did not understand the concept of being sick, those of pre-school age (3 to 6 years) were able to understand the difference between being well and being sick, and those older than 7 were aware of cancer [19]. A study on the ethical reasons for disclosure of cancer information to pediatric patients indicated that preadolescents should be told of their diagnosis if the child has the mental maturation to make decisions [20]. Yasar et al. previously reported preliminary findings from this study on the importance of updating leukemia diagnosis at an older age in small children diagnosed before the age of seven [21]. Disclosure should be done in a quiet setting by the parents and primary attending physician in this patient group. These steps are necessary to avoid adverse effects on a patient’s psychological and mental health in the future. We plan to add this detail to our routine informed consent form that parents sign when they have received detailed information about leukemia diagnosis.
In a previous study conducted in Turkey, physicians were affected approximately 2.2 times by patients’ relatives to disclose the diagnosis if they were not trained in delivering bad news [14]. In our study, 32% of the physicians and 16% of the nurses had received this type of training. Further, 86% of the interns had received this training before they graduated. Our study was limited with respect to sample size and diversity of patient groups, and all patients were not evaluated by a psychologist. Further research should be conducted with a higher number of various pediatric oncology patients in a prospective design. Based on our findings and the literature, we believe that “Delivering Bad News Training” education, which has been added to Turkey’s medical curriculum in recent years, is a positive step. This will lead to more standardized rules and recommendations that will better equip physicians to explain cancer diagnoses to patients within a framework of ethics, pediatric age, culture, and Turkish family structure.
Conclusions
Our research shows that there is no agreement among healthcare professionals and parents on the appropriate person, time, and place to inform children of a leukemia diagnosis in Turkey. The findings also highlight the importance of reinforming children diagnosed at less than 7 years when they are older. Furthermore, delivering bad news training to healthcare providers and providing psychological support to parents and adolescents have a positive impact.
Author Statements
Conflicts of Interest
The authors have no conflict of interest.
Funding
This investigation has no funded.
References
- Ferraton-Rollin M, Magné N, Gonthier R, Merrouche Y, Bois C. L’annonce du diagnostic de cancer: point de vue du médecin généraliste [The announcement of the diagnosis of cancer: point of view of the general practitioner]. Bull Cancer. 2013; 100: 955-962.
- Rutten LJ, Arora NK, Bakos AD, Aziz N, Rowland J. Information needs and sources of information among cancer patients: a systematic review of research (1980-2003). Patient Educ Couns. 2005; 57: 250-261.
- Dobrozsi S, Trowbridge A, Mack JW, Rosenberg AR. Effective Communication for Newly Diagnosed Pediatric Patients With Cancer: Considerations for the Patients, Family Members, Providers, and Multidisciplinary Team. Am Soc Clin Oncol Educ Book. 2019; 39: 573-581.
- Butow PN, Tattersall MH, Goldstein D. Communication with cancer patients in culturally diverse societies. Ann N Y Acad Sci. 1997; 809: 317-329.
- Oken D. What to tell cancer patients. A study of medical attitudes. JAMA. 1961; 175: 1120-1128.
- Surbone A. Cultural aspects of communication in cancer care. Support Care Cancer. 2008; 16: 235-240.
- Farhat F, Othman A, El Baba G, Kattan J. Revealing a cancer diagnosis to patients: attitudes of patients, families, friends, nurses, and physicians in Lebanon-results of a cross-sectional study. Curr Oncol. 2015; 22: e264-272.
- Alsirafy SA, Abdel-Kareem SS, Ibrahim NY, Abolkasem MA, Farag DE. Cancer diagnosis disclosure preferences of family caregivers of cancer patients in Egypt. Psychooncology. 2017; 26: 1758-1762.
- Wu J, Wang Y, Jiao X, Wang J, Ye X, Wang B. Differences in practice and preferences associated with truth-telling to cancer patients. Nurs Ethics. 2021; 28: 272-281.
- Li JY, Liu C, Zou LQ, Huang MJ, Yu CH, et al. To tell or not to tell: attitudes of Chinese oncology nurses towards truth telling of cancer diagnosis. J Clin Nurs. 2008; 17: 2463-2470.
- Mostafavian Z, Shaye ZA, Farajpour A. Mothers’ preferences toward breaking bad news about their children cancer. J Family Med Prim Care. 2018; 7: 596-600.
- Tsoussis S, Papadogiorgaki M, Markodimitraki E, Delibaltadakis G, Strevinas A, et al. Disclosure of cancer diagnosis: the Greek experience. J BUON. 2013; 18: 516-526.
- Lavrentiadis G, Manos N, Christakis J, Semoglou C. The Greek cancer patient’s knowledge and attitudes towards his diagnosis and prognosis. Psychother Psychosom. 1988; 49: 171-178.
- Ozdogan M, Samur M, Artac M, Yildiz M, Savas B, et al. Factors related to truth-telling practice of physicians treating patients with cancer in Turkey. J Palliat Med. 2006; 9: 1114-1119.
- Keles Gulnerman E, Cam Y, Elbasan B, Soysal S, Kaya Z, et al. The contribution of neurocognitive situation, physical capacity and daily life activities to quality of life in childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemia survivors. Turk J Med Sci. 2021; 51: 2510-2515.
- Gormez V, Kilincaslan A, Ebesutani C, Orengul AC, Kaya I, et al. Psychometric Properties of the Parent Version of the Revised Child Anxiety and Depression Scale in a Clinical Sample of Turkish Children and Adolescents. Child Psychiatry Hum Dev. 2017; 48: 922-933.
- Raz H, Tabak N, Kreitler S. Psychosocial Outcomes of Sharing a Diagnosis of Cancer with a Pediatric Patient. Front Pediatr. 2016; 4: 70.
- Kadan-Lottick NS, Robison LL, Gurney JG, Neglia JP, Yasui Y, et al. Childhood cancer survivors’ knowledge about their past diagnosis and treatment: Childhood Cancer Survivor Study. JAMA. 2002; 287: 1832-1839.
- Meriggi F, Andreis F, Liborio N, Codignola C, Rizzi A, et al. Parents with cancer: Searching for the right balance between telling the truth and protecting children. Palliat Support Care. 2017; 15: 88-97.
- Hudson N, Spriggs M, Gillam L. Telling the truth to young children: Ethical reasons for information disclosure in paediatrics. J Paediatr Child Health. 2019; 55: 13-17.
- Yasar Y, Kaya Z, Guney E, Kirkiz S, Koçak U. The Assessment of the Knowledge, Attitudes, Anxiety, and Coping Strategies of Pediatric Patients and Parents After a Leukemia Diagnosis in Turkiye. Turk J Haematol. 2023; 2.
Download PDF