Antenatal Screening and Diagnosis of B-thalassemia in High-Risk Population of Sardinia

Monni G; Ibba RM; Murgia F; Ventrella A; Murru S

Mini Review

Ann Hematol Oncol. 2022; 9(5): 1410.

Antenatal Screening and Diagnosis of ß-thalassemia in High-Risk Population of Sardinia

Monni G¹*, Ibba RM¹, Murgia F¹, Ventrella A² and Murru S²

¹Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Prenatal and Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis and Fetal Therapy, Microcitemico Hospital, Italy

²Department of Genetics and Genomics, Microcitemico Hospital, Italy

*Corresponding author: Monni G, Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Prenatal and Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis and Fetal Therapy, Microcitemico Hospital “A. Cao”, via Edward Jenner SNC, 09121, Cagliari, Italy

Received: September 22, 2022; Accepted: October 26, 2022; Published: November 02, 2022

Abstract

Sardinia, an Italian island in the Mediterranean sea with a population of 1,7 millions, has one of the highest incidence of β-thalassemia with 10-12% of carriers.

Since 1977 we have been offering a capillary screening program and prenatal diagnosis to couples following non-directive genetic counselling.

Thanks to the implementation of new molecular analysis methods, we shifted from prenatal diagnosis performed in 2nd trimester of pregnancy to 1st trimester. In order to avoid termination of pregnancy in case of affected fetuses following prenatal diagnosis we introduced preimplantation genetic testing, thus increasing notably the acceptance rate of antenatal screening and diagnosis by couples at high risk.

In this paper, we report the continuous experience of our prenatal centre in Sardinia in 9,324 antenatal diagnoses of β-thalassemia, the accuracy and safety related to the prenatal procedures we employed, the termination of pregnancy rate and the couples’ acceptance of the different approaches as well as analyze the screening programs available to the Sardinian population.

Molecular screening by Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) based methods, prenatal diagnosis by Chorionic Villous Sampling (CVS) with very low fetal loss rate (0,3%) and Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis (PGD) were the most common techniques applied in our prenatal centre and they have brought to a drastical reduction of newborns affected by β-thalassemia to only 3-5 per year.

Keywords: Thalassemia; Molecular screening; DNA; Prenatal and preimplantation genetic diagnosis; Termination of pregnancy

Abbreviations

Chorionic Villous Sampling (CVS), Quantitative Fluorescent Polymerase Chain Reaction (QF-PCR), Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis (PGD), Transabdominal CVS (TA-CVS), Termination of Pregnancy (TOP), Prenatal Diagnosis (PD)

Introduction

β-thalassemia is the most common inherited autosomal recessive disease in the world with more than 200,000 million carriers and 250,000 affected babies are born every year. The disease is widespread mostly in the Mediterranean region, North Africa, Middle East, Far East and East Asia. However, due to the complex migration trends, β-thalassemia is also diffused worldwide [1].

Sardinia, an Italian island in the Mediterranean sea with a population of 1,7 millions is at high risk incidence of β-thalassemia, with 10-12% of carriers which means that nowadays about 1 of 50 couples are at risk of genetic transmission of this disorder. In absence of prevention by antenatal genetic screening and diagnosis and with the progressive denatality in Sardinia, the affected newborns are estimated to be about 60-70 per year [2].

People affected by β-thalassemia are characterized by severe haemolitic anemia, hepatosplenomegaly and characteristic skeletal malformations such as osteoporosis and dysmorphic facies. Without prevention and therapy their survival and life quality is highly compromised and generally difficult.

Affected people necessitate regular blood transfusion and iron chelation. Bone marrow transplantation from an HLA identical sibling is the only possibility to cure the disease with a success rate of 90% [3].

β-thalassemia is characterized by absent to minimal hemoglobin A (0-30%), variable hemoglobin A2 (2-5%), and hemoglobin F (95- 70%). More than 200 different molecular defects have been described and 95% of them cause β-globin gene joint mutations [4].

In this paper we describe the prevention of β-thalassemia performed in our Ob/Gyn Department in Cagliari, Sardinia by antenatal molecular screening, prenatal and preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) in the last 45 years from 1977 to 2022 using different diagnostic approaches.

Identification of Carriers and Molecular Screening

A voluntary β-thalassemia screening program in Sardinia was launched in 1974-75 involving mass media, family doctors, obstetricians, pediatricians, geneticists, midwives and students of all ages in order to inform the whole population on its transmission and prevention and to provide blood testing in order to identify the carriers and the molecular mutations [5].

The most commonly identified point mutation (95,7%) in Sardinia was c.118C>T [4] (Table 1).

Table 1: Frequency of β-thalassemia mutations in Sardinia.








  

    Mutations

     

    %

  

  

    β -39 

    (C->T)

    95,7

  

  

    β -6 

    (-A)

    2,2

  

  

    β -76 

    6

    0,7

  

  

    β I-110 

    (G->A)

    0,5

  

  

    β II-745 

    (C->G)

    0,4

  

  

    β -87 

    (C->G)

    0,2

  

  

    β I-6 

    (T->C)

    0,2

  

  

    β 1 

    (-G)

    0,1

  

  

    β II -1 

    (G->A)

    0,1

  

  

    β I -1 

    (G->A)

    0,03






Table 1: Frequency of β-thalassemia mutations in Sardinia.

Since parental mutations had to be investigated on fetal material, the molecular definition of the parents’ ß-globin genotype was necessarily required.

Couples at risk were mostly identified and classified as composed of ß-thalassemia carriers on the base of whole blood count and haemoglobin electrophoresis.

The ß-globin gene defects were detected by:

- Reverse hybridization (Nuclear Laser Medicine, ß-globin test) able to identify, in a single step, up to 25 mutations in Mediterranean population [6].

- Sanger sequencing of the amplified ß-globin gene, to identify other less common variants.

- Amplification Refractory Mutation System - a primer-specific amplification [7].

- Most rarely, Multiplex Ligation Probe Amplification, to find out gene deletions and duplications [8].

Since 1994 we performed prenatal diagnosis by Chorionic Villous Sampling (CVS) and the villi were carefully cleaned under inverted microscope from the maternal decidua and blood clots. After a sample incubation at 56°C for 2 hours with a proteinase K digestion mix, fetal DNA was isolated using QIAmpDNA mini kit (Qiagen) with an automatic system (QiaCube, Qiagen) maternal cell contamination on prenatal samples was ruled out by short tandem repeat testing (Quantitative Fluorescent Polymerase Chain Reaction (QF-PCR)), Compact Devyser v3) [9].

DNA fetal samples were analysed by the same techniques described for the carrier study, but using two different procedures to limit misdiagnosis.

Molecular Analysis by Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis (PGD)

For PGD analysis of one embryo cell or of more cells from blastocysts we used molecular techniques for the detection of mutations based on PCR multiple steps to amplify the region of β-globin gene [10]. Two nested PCR reactions for producing DNA fragments were subsequently used for the analysis. Therefore, by minisequencing reaction we identified the β-globin gene mutations. Automatic sequencing, mini-sequencing, micro satellites analysis for linkage and genotyping by TaqMan analysis were also used [11,12].

Antenatal Diagnosis

In 1977 the first prenatal diagnosis of β-thalassemia in Europe was performed in our prenatal centre in Cagliari using Fetal Blood Sampling by Placentacentesis and globin chains synthesis analysis in the 2^nd trimester of pregnancy [13].

Later on, in 1981-82 we performed Fetoscopy and Cordocentesis by globin chain analysis [13].

In 1983, following the molecular improvement of PCR-based methods and thanks to new invasive procedures we shifted to Amniocentesis [14] and in 1984 we performed first trimester CVS. In the beginning, we carried out CVS using a transcervical rigid biopsy forceps [15]; but, since 1986 till present, CVS has been done only transabdominally [16] by free-hand technique under continuous ultrasound monitoring and it has been better accepted by patients [17].

Due to the strong request by couples, since 2002 we also offered PGD [10] by embryo biopsy and later on by blastocyst biopsy, only to infertile carrier couples initially and subsequently to fertile patients as well. An Italian Law adopted in 2004 prohibited PGD for several years but we were enabled to perform it again in 2014 thanks to the Italian Constitutional Supreme Court [18]. PGD is a more sophisticated method which can be carried out at the earliest stage of embyo development and it requires In Vitro Fertilization, transfer of non affected embryos and intracytoplasmatic sperm injection.

In Table 2 we report the results of fetal diagnosis in 9015 cases using different prenatal invasive techniques. Sampling failure, fetal loss rate and misdiagnosis were very low.

Table 2: Continuous invasive fetal diagnoses of ß-thalassemia in Sardinia in 9015 cases (1977-2022).








  

    Techniques

    No

    Years

    Gestational


      Age    (weeks)

    Failure


      (No)

    Fetal    loss (%)

    Misdiagnosis

  

  

    Placentacentesis 

    981

    1977-83

    18-24

    10

    5,2

    2

  

  

    Fetoscopy 

    67

    1983-85

    18-24

    2

    5,6

    -

  

  

    Cordocentesis 

    120

    1984-85

    18-24

    1

    2,1

    -

  

  

    Hepatic Vein Puncture

    3

    1984-86

    18-24

    -

    -

    -

  

  

    Cardiocentesis 

    3

    1984-86

    18-24

    -

    -

    -

  

  

    Amniocentesis 

    203

    1982-83

    16-18

    62

    2,6

    -

  

  

    Transcervical CVS1 

    572

    1983-86

    9-13

    12

    4,2

    1

  

  

    Transabdominal CVS1 

    7066

    1986-22

    6-24

    -

    0,4

    -

  

  

    1Chorionic Villus Sampling


      2 Due to DNA failure and completed by Fetal    Blood Sampling in 1984






Table 2: Continuous invasive fetal diagnoses of ß-thalassemia in Sardinia in

9015 cases (1977-2022).

The majority of women (98,2%) decided to interrupt voluntarily the pregnancy of affected fetuses following non-directive genetic counselling (Table 3).

Table 3: Fetal diagnosis of β-thalassemia 1977-2022.








  

     

    No

  

  

    Women 

    9015

  

  

    Normal fetuses 

    2247

  

  

    Health carriers 

    4523

  

  

    Affected fetuses

    22451 

  

  

    1 98,2% women opted for termination of pregnancy    following non-directive genetic counselling






Table 3: Fetal diagnosis of β-thalassemia 1977-2022.

The results of 309 PGD procedures are reported in (Table 4).

Table 4: Pre-implantation Genetic Diagnosis in Sardinia.








  

     

    No

  

  

    Women

    309

  

  

    Cycles

    342

  

  

    Stage of    biopsy 3 (blastomere) 

    195

  

  

    Stage of    biopsy 5 (blastocysts)

    114

  

  

    Miscarriages

    9

  

  

    Clinical    pregnancies

    67






Table 4: Pre-implantation Genetic Diagnosis in Sardinia.

All couples at high risk for β-thalassemia received informative genetic counselling based on the ethical principle of respect for authonomy. Informed written consent about initiating and managing the pregnancy was also obtained by the couples.

Discussion

Our continuous experience in applying β-thalassemia prevention programs in the high-risk population of Sardinia demonstrates their substential and permanent efficacy and safety as well as the high acceptance rate of the various diagnostic approaches offered to couples. The prevention programs adopted in Sardinia have contributed considerably to the decrease of the birth rate percentage of affected newborns [4].

In the 70’s, with 15,000-18,000 deliveries per year in Sardinia, about 120-130 newborns were affected by β-thalassemia. Nowadays, with natality of about 9,000-10,000 deliveries yearly and if prevention programs and prenatal and preimplantation genetic diagnosis were not available, the estimated birth percentage of affected newborns would be 60-70 per year. However, by applying efficient screening strategies, fetal diagnosis and PGD, only 3-5 children are born [19].

Since 1986, the only invasive diagnosis offered to carrier couples has been transabdominal CVS (TA-CVS) with the strong reduction of fetal loss related to the procedure (0,3%). TA-CVS was increasingly preferred to the other invasive techniques available; also, compared to transcervical CVS it is less traumatic and has less infections, less fetal loss rate and is generally better accepted by women (17). To those women who were referred to our prenatal centre after 13 weeks of gestation, we also offered 2nd trimester TA-CVS that has proven to be very safe and efficient [20].

PGD has also led to the strong acceptance of TA-CVS by the population, mostly in couples that have already had a termination of pregnancy (TOP) for an affected fetus [21] (Table 5).

Download PDF

Citation: Monni G, Ibba RM, Murgia F, Ventrella A and Murru S. Antenatal Screening and Diagnosis of β-thalassemia in High-Risk Population of Sardinia. Ann Hematol Oncol. 2022; 9(5): 1410.

Home

Journal Scope

Editorial Board

Instruction for Authors

Submit Your Article

Group	No. Women	Experience		Accepting PGD
Group	No. Women	PD	TOP	No. Women	% YES
1	60	YES	YES	60	100
2	60	YES	NO	18	30
3	60	NO	NO	15	25
Palomba ML. Hum Reprod 1994 CVS – Chorionic Villous Sampling PD – Prenatal Diagnosis PGD – Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis TOP – Termination of Pregnancy

Technique	Acceptance (%)
Fetal blood sampling	93.2
Amniocentesis	96.4
Chorionic villus sampling	99.3
Cao A. Prenat Diagn 1987