Perception of Care from Primary Caregivers, External Support and Psychosocial State of AIDS Orphans in High HIV Prevalence Regions of Ghana

Research Article

Austin J HIV/AIDS Res. 2015; 2(1): 1013.

Perception of Care from Primary Caregivers, External Support and Psychosocial State of AIDS Orphans in High HIV Prevalence Regions of Ghana

Lily Yarney¹*, Emmanuel Adjei², Kwame Asamoah¹, Justice Nyigma Bawole¹ and Albert Ahenkan¹

¹Department of Public Administration & Health Services Management, University of Ghana Business School, Ghana

²Department of Information Studies, University of Ghana, Ghana

*Corresponding author: Lily Yarney, Department of Public Administration & Health Services Management, University of Ghana Business School, Accra, Ghana

Received: May 20, 2015; Accepted: September 10, 2015; Published: September 28, 2015

Abstract

Background: Extended families of Africa in the past easily absorbed orphans, however, because of the increased numbers of orphans due to AIDS, and dwindling support from other sources, the extended family finds it difficult to cope with the AIDS orphan crisis. Empirical evidence indicates an elevated risk of psychosocial distress among AIDS orphans compared to non-orphans. The aim of the study was to determine adequacy of external support, to assess the psychosocial state of orphans, and to find out from orphans how they perceive and rate the care received from primary caregivers.

Methods: Two hundred and ninety-two AIDS orphans were purposively selected, and mixed-method of data collection was used. The quantitative data consisted of responses from orphans with interview questionnaires, whilst the qualitative data consisted of responses from in-depth interviews with 20 orphans.

Results: The majority of orphans-69.7% and 76.4% rated the support receive they from extended family and external sources respectively as poor. Only about21% rated care from primary caregiver as excellent. Although about 88% of orphans stay close to caregivers, almost 40% were unhappy or depressed.

Conclusion: We recommend that orphan care management policies and interventions should look into the relationship of orphans with their primary caregivers and the extended family support systems, and draw up programmes to improve these relationships and foster sense of belongingness for orphans.

Keywords: Orphans; External support; Psychosocial state; Care perception

Introduction

Where HIV prevalence rates have been high since the discovery of the virus in the early 1980s, children and adolescents have borne the brunt of the impact of AIDS. These children are faced with the problem of caring for their ill parents as well as fend for themselves and their younger siblings. Defining those children under age 18 years who have lost one or both parents to AIDS as AIDS orphans [1], most of them tend to live with grandparents and other family members of the extended family. These orphans usually find themselves in households that are faced with financial hardships, and high dependency ratio relative to their non-orphan counterparts [2-6]. Thus, they are confronted with material hardships, stigma and discrimination, socio-economic difficulties as well as psychological trauma.

African extended families in the past, absorbed orphans with little or no problem [7], however, because of the increasing numbers of orphans due to AIDS, and decreasing support from governments, Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs) and others, the extended family can no longer cope with the problem of orphans [8]. Thus, increasing numbers of orphans are falling away from the extended family protection system, resulting in child headed households, street children and child labour. Other researchers have also indicated that although the traditional extended family system finds it difficult to manage with the increasing numbers of orphans, the system in itself is not disintegrating, however, the wider society plays a critical role in its effectiveness in caring for orphans [9].

Although HIV prevalence is relatively low in Ghana compared to most parts of sub-Saharan Africa, there are areas within the country where HIV prevalence rates have risen above the threshold of 5% for some time and have experienced deaths from AIDS. These areas therefore have a sizeable population of orphans [10]. These orphans are disadvantaged compared to non-orphans in terms of the numerous problems that they are confronted with [2]. In spite of the increasing availability of programmes for prevention of HIV transmission and AIDS management interventions to reduce new infections, the impact of the previous HIV situation in these areas of Ghana will linger for decades because of its consequences on the present generation of orphans. Thus, it still demands that much attention is given to the situation of orphans in the country so that effective interventions can be drawn and implemented for the betterment of society.

Various research findings have indicated increased risk of psychosocial distress among children orphaned by AIDS compared to non-orphans with symptoms ranging from anger, anxiety, depression, post-traumatic stress, delinquency, conduct and peer relationship problems to suicidal tendencies [11-15]. Although governments, orphan care agencies and children’s organizations have taken cognisance of the psychosocial and emotional needs of orphans, and are struggling to incorporate psychosocial and emotional support into their intervention programming activities, there is the need for the specific areas of focus of psychosocial distress to be addressed, and this formed the basis for this study. The study was therefore carried out to determine whether Ghanaian orphans receive adequate external support of any kind, to assess the psychosocial state of these orphans, and to find out directly from orphans how they perceive and rate the care they receive from their primary caregivers.

Methods

The research was carried out between 2008 and 2011 in the Ashanti and Eastern Regions of Ghana. These Regions were purposively selected because of their high HIV prevalence rates over a long period of time since the discovery of HIV in the country in 1981 [16]. Consequently these two regions have seen relatively high numbers of children orphaned by AIDS, as a result, identification of AIDS orphans and access to information are easier relative to other regions of the country.

Two hundred and ninety-two (292) orphans between the ages of 5–17 years were selected purposively for the study. They consisted of one hundred and forty one (141) orphans from the Ashanti Region and one hundred and fifty-one (151) orphans from the Eastern Region. They were made up of single orphans- those who have lost either parent to AIDS and double orphans- those who have lost both parents to AIDS.

The research protocol met the guideline for research involving human subjects of the Ghana Health Service (GHS), with identification number GHS-ERC-13/3/08. Written and verbal assent were obtained from all literate and illiterate primary caregivers respectively on behalf of all orphans, additionally, consent was sought from all orphans before they were recruited into the study. Research procedures and purpose were explained carefully and thoroughly to allay the fears of all participants and confidentiality was assured and maintained for all participants throughout the study.

Mixed-method of data collection was used. Thus, all orphans aged 10 – 17 years answered interview questionnaires that sought information on their demographic characteristics, and emotional/ psychosocial state. They were also asked to rate the financial and material support they receive from sources other than their primary caregiver, and the care they receive from their primary caregiver. Primary caregivers assisted orphans aged 5 – 9 years (who formed only about 2% (6/292) of study orphans), to respond to the questionnaires, but these orphans rated their primary caregiver care independently. Relevant portions of the questionnaires from the Children’s Needs Assessment Tool Kit (CNA Toolkit, version 3, March, 2002) which is aimed at assisting organizations in assessing the needs of children in areas that are heavily impacted by HIV and AIDS were adapted in line with the objectives of the study and used. The qualitative data consisted of responses from in-depth interviews with 20 orphans aged 10 – 17 years pulled from the study participants: 10 from each of the two regions, using an interview guide.

Mixed-method of data collection was used. Thus, all orphans aged 10 – 17 years answered interview questionnaires that sought information on their demographic characteristics, and emotional/ psychosocial state. They were also asked to rate the financial and material support they receive from sources other than their primary caregiver, and the care they receive from their primary caregiver. Primary caregivers assisted orphans aged 5 – 9 years (who formed only about 2% (6/292) of study orphans), to respond to the questionnaires, but these orphans rated their primary caregiver care independently. Relevant portions of the questionnaires from the Children’s Needs Assessment Tool Kit (CNA Toolkit, version 3, March, 2002) which is aimed at assisting organizations in assessing the needs of children in areas that are heavily impacted by HIV and AIDS were adapted in line with the objectives of the study and used. The qualitative data consisted of responses from in-depth interviews with 20 orphans aged 10 – 17 years pulled from the study participants: 10 from each of the two regions, using an interview guide.

Results

Socio-Demographic characteristics of orphans

\

The ages of study orphans ranged from 5 to 17 years with an average age of 12.2 years, 151 (51.7%) were females and 141 (48.3%) were males. Seventy three percent (73%) were single orphans and the remaining 27% double orphans. The majority257 (88%) were inschool, whilst 35 (12%) were out-of school. Thirty one percent (31%) of orphans were living with their maternal or paternal uncles and aunties, 28.8% were with their grandparents, 34.6% were living with either parent and 5.1% were with their siblings (Table 1). During the in-depth interviews with orphans, it was however realized that some caregivers were friends of the deceased parent or friends of the family of the orphans. This information was not captured by the interview questionnaires.