Empirical Models for pH Correction and Their Implications for the Accuracy of the Carbonate System in Estuaries

Special Article: Environmental Chemistry

Austin Environ Sci. 2024; 9(3): 1115.

Empirical Models for pH Correction and Their Implications for the Accuracy of the Carbonate System in Estuaries

Carlos Augusto Ramos e Silva1-3*; Lucas Wanderley Gaudie-Ley2; Yaci Gallo Alvarez2; Marcelo dos Santos Sampaio2; Humberto Marotta3; Raimundo Damasceno3; Francisca Ferreira do Rosário3; José Antônio Baptista Neto2

1Department of Marine Biology, Federal Fluminense University, Brazil

2Postgraduate Program in Dynamics of Oceans and Earth, Federal Fluminense University, Brazil

3Center for Study of Water, Biomass and Oil (NAB), Federal Fluminense University, Niterói/RJ, ZIP code 24210-330, Brazil

*Corresponding author: Carlos Augusto Ramos e Silva, Department of Marine Biology, Federal Fluminense University, Niterói/RJ, ZIP code 24210-330, Brazil. Email: caugusto_99@yahoo.com

Received: November 09, 2024; Accepted: December 03, 2024; Published: December 10, 2024

Abstract

The estuary is one of the most variable ecosystems due to the influence of freshwater, seawater, and terrestrial inputs on its hydrodynamics, physicochemical, and biological processes. In these waters, pH affects carbonate system speciation and can be determined by potentiometry or spectrophotometry, with both methods being sensitive to common changes in temperature from ambient to in situ conditions, which are often not accounted for in some models. This study aimed to investigate the best-fit pH correction model using a Tris solution obtained at 25°C for various ambient temperatures, proposing different empirical models to correct pH for variable temperatures. The results indicated an important influence of pH correction at 25°C for in situ temperature on the carbonate system. Variations between 0.05 and 1.03 pH units caused large relative errors in different parameters of the carbonate system: CA (VC% from 6 to 188), Ω calcite (VC% from 4 to 82), Ω aragonite (VC% from 4 to 82), HCO3 - (VC% from 5 to 147), CO3 2- (VC% from 10 to 231), and DIC (VC% from 5 to 173). Our findings revealed that the newly proposed models can substantially improve the accuracy of determining carbonate system parameters in estuarine waters.

Keywords: pH measurement; Estuarine waters; Carbonate system; Empirical models; Guanabara Bay

Introduction

Estuarine waters commonly receive substantial inputs of organic matter and nutrients from urban and rural catchments [8]. These inputs can have substantial implications for the marine environment, including changes in pH levels that affect the equilibrium constants of the carbonate system [5]. The anthropogenic increase in atmospheric CO2 concentration and untreated organic effluents have led to decreases in both pH and carbonate concentrations in coastal waters over the past decades [21,28,34-39]. These growing reductions in pH are leading to ocean acidification [9], which poses a significant threat to marine organisms such as coccolithophores, corals, foraminifera, and bony fishes due to the increased concentration of H+ ions in seawater [12]. Accurate pH measurements are still needed for monitoring acidification and its impact on the speciation and quantification of the carbonate system, with errors less than 0.1 and 0.01 pH units, respectively [25].

In contrast to the stable salinity comparing field and the analysis site, seawater pH is typically determined at a standard temperature of 25°C (pH25), which often differs from in situ conditions. Due to the temperature dependence of the stoichiometric dissociation constants of the carbonate system (Ko*, K1* e K2*), pH25 measurements must be corrected to reflect the pH value at the sampling temperature (pHt). This correction requires incorporating a parameter of the carbonate system under thermodynamic conditions, such as dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC) or Total Alkalinity (TA), as established by previous studies [13,24]. However, empirical studies in the relationship between pH25 and pHt are still scarce. Based on an experimental design using Tris buffers for in-situ salinity and varying temperatures, our study aimed to propose new empirical models for converting pH25 to pHt, compare them with existing literature models, and assess their accuracy for determining carbonate system speciation in estuarine brackish waters.

Study area

Guanabara Bay is a eutrophic tropical coastal bay located on the southeastern coast of Brazil, with a surface area of 384 km², situated between latitudes 22° 41' - 22° 58' S and longitudes 43° 02' - 43° 18' W (Figure 1). The bay features a coastline spanning 131 km and an average water volume of approximately 1.87 x 109 m3. The bay's drainage basin covers approximately 4,080 km² and is intersected by 56 rivers and channels [17]. Salinity in Guanabara Bay ranges from 20 to 34 psu, with higher salinity observed in bottom waters. The temperature ranges from 14.8°C to 25.2°C in the bottom waters and from 19.6°C to 28.6°C at the surface [42].