App4Support: Supporting Volunteer Sports Coaches in Reading and Handling Difficult-to-Understand behaviors of Children; A Protocol Study

Special Article: Mental Health

Austin J Psychiatry Behav Sci. 2024; 10(1): 1100.

App4Support: Supporting Volunteer Sports Coaches in ‘Reading’ and Handling Difficult-to-Understand behaviors of Children; A Protocol Study

Sanne Bakker*; Janet Moeijes

Department of Human Movement and Education, Windesheim University of Applied Sciences, The Netherlands

*Corresponding author: Sanne Bakker Department of Human Movement and Education, Windesheim University of Applied Sciences, Campus 2-6, Zwolle, 8017, CA, The Netherlands. Email: s.bakker@windesheim.nl

Received: March 05, 2024 Accepted: April 10, 2024 Published: April 17, 2024

Abstract

Children with mild psychosocial problems are at significant risk of avoiding participation in sports club activities or leaving the sports club prematurely. Volunteer sports club coaches cannot ‘read’ and handle their difficult-to-understand behaviour adequately. The present study addresses the question: ‘What is the design and content of the prototype of an app that is helpful for volunteer sports club coaches in ‘reading’ and handling difficult-to-understand behaviour of children with mild psychosocial problems?’ The needs of volunteer sports club coaches for support on the playing field regarding supervising children with difficult-to-understand behaviour are explored through semi-structured interviews and focus groups with volunteer sports coaches and professional sports coach advisors, semi-structured interviews with children and their parents, and sports training session observations. This will result in an overview of various forms of difficult-to-understand behaviour of children during sports club. Subsequently, rules of thumb for volunteer sports club coaches on how to deal with diverse forms of difficult-to-understand behaviour will be formulated. Finally, a framework for an app prototype will be sketched. To conclude, we are facing the challenge of developing the prototype of a mobile app to prevent sports drop-out of children with mild psychosocial problems displaying difficult-to-understand behaviour.

Keywords: Difficult-to-understand behaviour; Psychosocial problems; Sports participation; M-health; Volunteer Sports coaches; Sports coach advisors

Introduction

Sports participation benefits a child's physical and psychosocial health [1-3]. Psycho-social health can be defined as the absence or lower levels of internalising problems and externalising problems on the one hand and the presence or higher levels of appropriate social behaviour on the other [3,4]. Internalising problems are behaviours reflected in emotional disorders (i.e. depression and anxiety disorders), such as social withdrawal, sadness and peer problems. Externalising problems are those associated with behavioural problems such as oppositional defiant disorder, conduct disorder, and Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorders (AD/HD). They can manifest as delinquency and aggression [5]. Lastly, prosocial behaviour refers to voluntary actions intended to benefit others, such as helping peers or sharing toys [6]. With approximately 69% of the children aged 6-11 being a member of a sports club in 2022 [7], organised sport is the most prominent form of children's sports participation in the Netherlands. Organised sports participation has previously been shown to be correlated with lower prevalence of internalising [3,8-12] and externalising problems [11-15] and higher levels of prosocial behaviour, especially in boys [11,12,16-18]. Longitudinal research highlighted the importance of organised sports participation for children's psychosocial health by showing that membership of a sports club and a higher frequency of sport participation have a beneficial influence on children's level of internalising problems [3,19,20] and their prosocial behaviour [3]. Studies in the Netherlands found for children aged 10-12 that 5.4-6.9% had abnormal scores for internalising problems, 15.5-17.7% had abnormal scores for externalising problems and 6.5-7.6% had abnormal scores for prosocial behaviour [3,11]. Although the children with abnormal scores could benefit most from participation in organised sports, they are most at risk of leaving the sports club after a short time [3,10]. One of the most dominant factors related to sports drop-out in children and adolescents is the participants' perceptions of their physical or sports competence [21]. Children with internalised problems tend to perceive their competence to be lower than their peers [22,23]. Nevertheless, organised sport is a context which can facilitate opportunities for Positive Youth Development (PYD) [24]. PYD aims to realise the youth's potential by emphasising strengths and opportunities rather than problems and deficits [25,26]. Most importantly, volunteer sport coaches play a significant role in developing these positive experiences, as organised sport only stimulates PYD when the coaches and peers provide positive guidance and parental involvement is present [27].

However, for children with mild psychosocial problems, organised sports can also be a context in which they are (again) confronted with negative experiences. These adverse experiences are mainly caused by the difficult-to-understand behaviour that these children often show at the sports club [23,28]. Difficult-to-understand behaviour can be described as behaviour that can’t be directly understood when shown by a person. It can be an expression of incomprehension, unhappiness, pain or fear. The behaviour can be aggressive, withdrawn or anxious. Examples include inhibited behaviour towards other children or abruptly leaving the field [23]. Children who are not supervised by skilled coaches are more likely to be confronted with negative experiences at the sports club [29-31]. Most youth sports coaches in the Netherlands are volunteers without pedagogical baggage. These volunteer sports coaches are insufficiently equipped to deal with the difficult-to-understand behaviour that children with mild psychosocial problems may display [32]. Therefore, it is crucial to develop interventions to support volunteer youth sports coaches when confronted with difficult-to-understand behaviour to prevent sports drop-out.

According to the recent growth of the application of mobile phone apps in sports activities, an app-based intervention is suitable to reach volunteer sport coaches. At thetime of writing, a wide variety of mobile phone applications in the form of digital apps has been developed in the Netherlands to support sports coaches in various ways. Consider, for example, the apps for team management (e.g. De Voetbal Trainer, Mingle Sport, HandbalNL, and Yoursportplanner.com), creating training exercises (e.g. RINUS, FeetOn and Go4Hockey), making training schedules (e.g. FeetOn, GoFox and Handbaltrainer) and providing tactical sport-specific information (e.g. Opstellings fout!, Hand-balCoach and FeetOn), with some having over 12.000 registered coaches as users (e.g. FeetOn). However, there is currently no app available to support volunteer sports coaches in their dealing with children showing difficult-to-understand behaviour due to mild psychosocial problems.

Hence, the App4Support project aims to answer the following research question: What is the design and content of the prototype of an app that is helpful for volunteer sports coaches in 'reading' and handling difficult-to-understand behaviour of children with mild psychosocial problems?

Materials and Methods

Study Design and Participants

The App4Support project aims to develop an app prototype that supports volunteer sports coaches in 'reading' and handling difficult-to-understand behaviour of children with mild psychosocial problems. For this purpose, a practice based iterative mixed-method study will be conducted. A combination of interviews, focus groups and observations will be utilized.

Semi-structured interviews with volunteer sports coaches and professional sports coach advisors will pertain to (1) the problems encountered by volunteer sports coaches when responding to difficult-to-understand behaviour of children with mild psychosocial 100 problems and (2) possible solutions suggested by professional sports coach advisors. Volunteer sports coaches and professional sport coach advisors will be recruited by Sportservice Zwolle and Sportpunt Houten, two Dutch non-profit organizations which have connections with sports clubs and their volunteer sports coaches.

Furthermore, sports training sessions will be observed to identify and analyse the difficult-to-understand behaviours displayed by children and the reactions of volunteer sport coaches to these behaviours. Volunteer sport coaches willing to participate in the training session observations will be recruited through convenience sampling, through the researchers' personal network.

In addition, short semi-structured interviews will be held with children aged 6-13 years and their parents or guardians about experiences and desires with respect to the children's sport participation. Participating volunteer sports coaches will approach the children and their parents or guardians for recruitment, as they have prior knowledge on which children display difficult-to-understand behaviour and are in touch with their parents.

Moreover, the participating volunteer sport coaches and professional sport coach advisors will be asked to participate in focus groups in which the first provisional design and content of the app prototype is discussed.

1. The following categories of persons meet the inclusion criteriaVolunteer youth sports coaches who supervise children from 6 to 13 years of age;

2. Professional sports coach advisors who have experience in supporting volunteer youth sports coaches

3. Children with difficult-to-understand behaviour from 6 to 13 years of age;

4. Parents or guardians of children with difficult-to-understand behaviour from 6 to 13 years of age.

The following categories of persons are excluded from the study:

1. Volunteer youth sports coaches younger than 16 years of age;

2. Children who attend a school for special education;

3. Children younger than 6 yours or older than 13 years of age.

Data collection for this study will take place from March 2024 to February 2025. All study procedures are in accordance with and approved by the medical ethical committee of the University Medical Centre Groningen, the Netherlands (M23.320767). The study will be conducted according to the principles expressed in the Declaration of Helsinki. All participants and/or their legal representatives will be asked to provide informed consent prior to taking part in the study. They will also be informed about the opportunity to withdraw from the study at any stage. Codes instead of names will be used when quoting information given by the participants.

Procedures

Interviews with Volunteer Youth Sports Coaches and Professional Sports Coach Advisors: Semi-structured interviews will be conducted with volunteer sport coaches and professional sport coach advisors to gain insight into problems encountered when 'reading' difficult-to-understand behaviour and finding possible solutions. In order to gain more detailed insights into different varieties of difficult-to-understand behaviour encountered by volunteer youth sports coaches during sports training sessions, the interview questions were structured along eight types of such behaviour. A number of these types of behaviour were distinguished on the basis of the Strength and Difficulties Questionnaire (SDQ) [33], the 'Rose of Leary' [34] and practise-based guidelines from Niks and Van den Dool [23]. The various types of a child’s difficult-to-understand behaviour were further elaborated by insights provided by pilot interviews with professional sports coach advisors and colleague researchers. The definitively determined eight types of behaviour and their sources are shown in Table 1.