Intervention Using a Leaflet to Promote a Morning-typed Life in 2- to 6-Year-old Japanese Children and their Parents

Review Article

Austin J Nutri Food Sci. 2014;2(6): 1035.

Intervention Using a Leaflet to Promote a Morning-typed Life in 2- to 6-Year-old Japanese Children and their Parents

Tetsuo Harada1*, Kiyoe Saito1, Kai Wada1, Fujiko Tsuji1,2,3, Milada Krejci2,3, Teruki Noji4, Takahiro Kawada5, Miyo Nakade6 and Hitomi Takeuchi1

1Department of Environmental Physiology, Kochi University, Japan

2Department of Health Education, University of South Bohemia, Czech Republic

3University of Physical Education and Sport, PALESTRA in Prague, Czech Republic

4Department of Physical Education, Kochi University, Japan

5Aoyama-Gakuin University, Japan

6Department of Nutritional Management, Tokai Gakuen University, Japan

*Corresponding author: :Tetsuo Harada, Department of Environmental Physiology, Faculty of Education, Kochi University, Akebonocho, Kochi 780-8520, Japan

Received: June 17, 2014; Accepted: July 10, 2014; Published: July 15, 2014

Abstract

We created a new educational material focused on three benefits of a morning-typed lifestyle and actual strategies for promoting this lifestyle. The material is a leaflet entitled, "Three benefits from going to bed early, getting up early and having breakfast. Message to mothers and fathers of young children"! In the present study, we attempted to evaluate the educational efficacy of a month-long intervention using this leaflet on 2- to 6-year-old Japanese children. About 1200 children and their parents were asked to participate in a month-long intervention from mid-June, 2011. Just before and three months after the intervention period, an anonymous integrated questionnaire was administered to participants. After the first administration of the questionnaire was done before the intervention, an envelope including a letter for parents and the leaflet was distributed through each of 10 nursery schools. The letter has the message of the purpose of the study and recommendation of following the habits shown by the leaflet for one month. Responses were received from 61% of pairs (children: 363 girls and 375 boys; parents 689 mothers and 56 fathers). Children tended to be more morning-typed after the intervention than before the intervention (p=0.07), but there was no significant difference in the Diurnal Type Scale (DTS) scores of their parents. The body mass index (BMI) of the children was significantly lower three months after the intervention period than just before the intervention (p=0.04).In the children, implementation scores were significantly correlated with their post-intervention DTS scores (p=0.001), but not with post-intervention BMI. The intervention program particularly increased morning-typed lifestyles in children through the limitation of TV and video games.

Keywords: Intervention; Leaflet; Morning-typed lifestyle; Diurnal type scale; Body mass index; young Japanese children; 2-6 years old; Video games and TV watching

Introduction

Current sleep health problems in young children

Several sleep health-related problems have been reported around the world in preschool-aged children. In a cohort study in Melbourne, Australia, sleep problems in young infants could not predict the long-term outcomes at six years of age [1]. A worldwide questionnaire study on preschool children from Asian countries (China, Hong Kong, India, Japan, Korea Malaysia, Philippines, Singapore and Thailand) and Caucasian countries (Australia, New Zealand, Canada, the United Kingdom and the United States) showed that young children from Asian countries had later bedtimes, shorter night sleep hours and a higher frequency of perceiving sleep problems than children from Caucasian countries [2]. Poorer sleep in five-year-olds in the UK was related to anxiety/depression and aggression [3].

A questionnaire study on 39,813 Japanese children aged 4.5 years old as part of a nationwide cross-sectional survey in Japan showed13.7% of children to have a total of less than 10 hours of sleep a day [4]. In that survey, a high odds ratios for shorter duration of sleep was associated with living in a less populous area, long hours spent watching TV, longer maternal working hours and attending preschool. An epidemiological study using a 1-week actigraph to measure activity in Japanese five-year-olds showed that culture-related extracurricular lessons were associated with a later bedtime in girls. On the other hand, participation in a sports group and having a fixed bathing time were related to earlier wakeup time in the morning. Sports groups were also related to higher sleep efficiency [5]. In a cross-sectional questionnaire study administered to a cohort of 1,656 kindergarten children in Jintan City, Jingsu, China, 39.4%, 31.6%, 28.0%, 24.7%, 23.4%, and 29.6% of the children had difficulty initiating sleep, nightmares, sleep talking, sleeping less, sleep resistance and fatigue, respectively [6]. Moreover, fatigue in children was associated with a lower IQ. A review of the literature from the past few years suggests that children are getting less sleep and becoming more evening-typed. Shorter sleep resulting from an evening-typed lifestyle is associated with the 24-hour commercialization of society [7,8], and may reduce the mental health of children [9-12].

Children's sleep and maternal health

A questionnaire study on 9- to 15-month-old and 48- to 55-month-old children and their mothers living in Israel suggested that the mothers' thoughts and feelings on their own childhood help form their sleep-related concerns and practices concerning their children [13]. A questionnaire study on more than 1600 mother-infant pairs (prenatal cohort study at 6months, 1year and 2 years) living in eastern Massachusetts, USA showed that maternal depression during pregnancy, early introduction of solid foods, infant TV viewing, and attendance in child care may be risk factors for shorter infant sleep duration [14].

Based on a questionnaire study on 156 primary caregiver-child pairs in the United States, bedtime resistance and daytime sleepiness in children have salient associations with parenting stress that is related to daytime behavioral problems in children with insomnia [15]. In a literature review, Lee [16] pointed out that the mothers of children with developmental disabilities (the number of which is now increasing worldwide) experienced high levels of stress as well as poor sleep and poor well-being.

The physical and mental health of young children may be very closely linked.

Relationship between sleep habits and obesity in young children

Objective data obtained with triaxial accelerometers from low-income African American eight-year-olds demonstrated that obesity in this age group is associated with characteristics of inactivity and short sleep, while children with higher reading activity were moderate-vigorous [17]. A questionnaire study and partially longitudinal follow-up were administered to 380 low-income preschool children in the Mid-west of the U.S. [18]. Longer nocturnal sleep and a smaller sleep phase difference of less than 45 minutes between weekdays and weekends were associated with a lower risk of future increases in BMI. A questionnaire study on 1,311 Chinese children aged3 to 4 years from 10 kindergarten classes in Shanghai gave on odds ratio for childhood obesity of 4.76 for children with less than 9 hours of sleep and 3.42 for those with 9.0-9.4 hours of sleep in comparison with those with more than 11 hours of sleep [19]. Short sleep duration in children was associated with short sleep duration in mothers, high education carrier of mothers and co-sleeping of children with their mothers. In one study, obese preschool-aged children in the U.S. participated in a weight management program, and pre- and post-treatment assessments of body mass, caloric intake and sleep were performed [20]. Longer post-treatment nocturnal sleep was associated with lower post-treatment BMI and lower caloric intake.

Sleep education programs for young children throughout the world

In general, sleep education is very limited worldwide, even in medical schools. To assess the prevalence of sleep education (fundamental knowledge and knowledge of sleep disorders) in medical school education, a questionnaire survey was administered to 409 medical schools in 12 countries (Australia, India, Indonesia, Japan, Malaysia, New Zealand, Singapore, South Korea, Thailand, the U.S., Canada and Vietnam) [21]. The average time spent on sleep education was just under 2.5 hours, with 27% of the schools responding with "0" hours. Australia, USA and Canada provided more than 3 hours of education on sleep. Pediatric sleep topics were covered in a mere 17 minutes compared to over 2 hours on adult sleep-related topics.

Owens et al. [22] reviewed intervention studies on recovery from sleep disorders and concluded that some treatments appear effective for some infants and children with sleep problems in families that are willing to undertake behavioral and cognitive behavioral interventions. In Malaysia, there are two common perspectives regarding sleep health education, and both result in a poor understanding of sleep among science teachers and students. A systematic sleep health education system is needed for the Muslim population in Malaysia [23]. An online, self-paced, sleep medicine learning module as an educational tool improved the overall sleep knowledge of students at Johns Hopkins Medical School compared to control students who learned a sham module [24]. In a review paper, Cassoff et al. [25] showed that school-based sleep promotion programs are not often successful because the enhanced sleep knowledge learned in the programs does not lead to sustained changes in sleep behavior. To resolve this problem, they proposed using individually tailored approaches to promote sleep health.

The effects of intervention classes (psychology classes) to promote sleep health were evaluated in eleventh grade students at three co-educational secondary schools in Adelaide, Australia [26]. Students in the intervention classes (n=51) attended four 50-minute-long sleep education classes held once a week. The classes were modified from those developed by Moseley and Gradisar [27] and included a motivational interviewing framework. The intervention group increased their knowledge on sleep compared to the control group (n=53). Students' motivation to regulate their own wake up times improved during the intervention. The intervention group also had increased motivation to lengthen the duration of their sleep time [28]. Sateia et al. [29] developed an education program that included a broad range of topics in sleep physiology and medicine and measured the effectiveness of intervention using this new program on first year medical school students in the U.S. Evaluation showed that the effectiveness of the intervention using the new program was significant. Recently, Ribeiro and Stickgold [30] discussed the potential sleep applications in the school setting and "sleep and learning" that can be taught in schools, based on the past decade of findings on rapid eye movement (REM) sleep as a key process for memory consolidation and re-construction.

Few sleep education programs have focused on circadian typology, and especially on a morning-typed lifestyle. We therefore created a new educational material focused on the three benefits of a morning-typed lifestyle and actual strategies for promoting such a lifestyle. The material is a leaflet entitled, "Three benefits from going to bed early, getting up early and having breakfast. Message to mothers and fathers of young children"! In the present study, we attempted to evaluate the educational efficacy of a month-long intervention using this leaflet on 2- to 6-year-old Japanese children.

Methods

Intervention study

A month-long intervention program starting in mid-June, 2011 was administered to about 1200 young children and their parents (Figure1) (Table 1). Before (late May 2011) and three months after (mid-October 2011) the intervention month, an anonymous integrated questionnaire was administered to the 1200 pairs. After the first administration of the questionnaire was done before the intervention, an envelope including a letter for parents and the leaflet was distributed to every parent through each of 10 nursery schools. The letter has the message of the purpose of the study and recommendation of "following the habits shown by the leaflet for one month". An envelope including the questionnaire was distributed to every parents through each of 10 nursery schools, just before and three months after the intervention month. Responses were received from 61% of the pairs (children: 363 girls and 375 boys; parents 689 mothers and 56 fathers). Parents answered the pre- and post-intervention questionnaires by themselves and on behalf of their children.